Lake Susan Real Estate
Central Florida's Premier Luxury Community
Welcome To Lake Susan, Florida
Lake Susan is one of the hidden gems of the Clermont Chain of Lakes. Nestled between Lake Louisa and Lake Minnehaha, it’s a smaller, more intimate body of water surrounded by natural shoreline and swampland, giving it a secluded, almost untouched feel. Connected by the Crooked River to the south and a short channel to Minnehaha on the north, Lake Susan serves as a quiet passage in the chain — perfect for boaters who want a slower pace before opening up into the larger lakes. Its calm waters and natural setting make it especially appealing to buyers seeking privacy and a true lakefront lifestyle, while still being just minutes from Clermont’s growing downtown.
Lake Susan
Scarcity drives value: With only two named subdivisions and a handful of custom estates, lakefront inventory is extremely limited.
Premium over Clermont average: Lake Susan homes trade at ~2x the Clermont median ($482k) due to direct water access and exclusivity.
Buyer profile: Affluent buyers seeking privacy, boating lifestyle, and proximity to Orlando’s growth corridor.
Takeaway: While Clermont’s overall market is cooling slightly in value growth, Lake Susan remains a premium micro‑market with very low turnover and strong pricing power. Homes here are holding value well above city averages, especially those with private docks and modernized interiors.
Properties in other lakefront communities along the larger lakes of the Clermont Chain are maintaining elevated values, a reflection of the exclusivity and demand tied to their waterfront setting.
Susans Landing
- Gated Lakefront Community
- on the Clermont Chain of Lakes with private boat ramp and fishing pier
- Direct Access to Lake Susan and the full chain — ideal for boating, skiing, and waterfront living
- Spacious Homes built between 1998–2006, typically 2,100–3,600+ sq ft with 3–5 bedrooms
- Generous Lot Sizes (0.29–0.65 acres), many with mature landscaping and private docks
- HOA Value: Low annual fees (~$525–$650) covering gated entry, common areas, and lake amenities
- Strong Market Performance: Recent sales in the $550K–$940K range, with lakefront homes commanding premium pricing
1940s: Founded by Bernard Bickel, Lake Susan Lodge began as a collection of cottages and a lodge that quickly became a favorite for fishermen and vacationers. Its location on the Clermont Chain of Lakes made it a natural draw for anglers seeking trophy bass and families looking for a rustic getaway.
Peak Popularity (1970s–1980s)
- The lodge expanded beyond fishing to become a weekend hotspot.
- It offered seafood dining, live music, and dancing, attracting crowds who came by both car and boat.
- Locals recall the parking lot buzzing with laughter, music spilling out, and boats pulling in and out of the marina.
- July 2016
- A fire destroyed 30–40% of the building, leaving it abandoned for several years
- 2020
- The property was sold for $1.2 million. Plans were announced to replace the lodge with a 10,000 sq ft Tuscan‑style mansion and event venue, including a spa, café, and limited overnight accommodations.
- Click on the title of picture for a quick video of Lake Susans Lodge as I remembered it.